The more I think about it, the more I get used to the idea of Carey as Daisy? But Tobey - no. No no no no no. (Nick needs to be like, a Richard Gere type, only younger. Someone like John Krasinski - tall and awkward and a little prudish, but still laid back, you know?)

But Gatsby, OMG OMG NO. I literally cannot put anyone but Redford in the role. It makes my heart and my head hurt.